
I’m going to come clean at the start of this post: I’m not 100% sure what the heck is going on in this Glamour cover from 1944. My best guess is based on the knowledge that both women are wearing the same coat. Yes, different colors, but it is the same coat from Swansdown.
The coat sensation of the year is short, boxy, versatile. It goes anywhere, any time. Wear it in the city, the country, the evening.
So, is this a case of “seeing oneself on the street” embarrassment? My guess is that explains the shocked and slightly belligerent looks the women are exchanging.
You younger readers may not remember a time when wearing the same outfit as another woman was a cause for extreme embarrassment. I remember hearing tales of women who arrived at a party to find another woman wearing her dress, and then sneaking out to race home and change. It even happened to Mamie Eisenhower in 1955, and the event was such a big deal that it was reported in Time magazine.
Today, it seems that problem has been solved. I give partial credit to the IT bag. You know, the bag of the moment that everyone who is anyone is carrying this season. This summer the IT bag was from Celine, and so many people have been carrying it that Bill Cunningham gave it a mention in his weekly video.
And then there is the casual “uniform” that so many people have adopted. Who cares if you pass someone on the street who is also wearing jeans, a black tee and a grey hoodie?
Or maybe it is still a cause for embarrassment in some circles. In this case, three women wore the same gown, one changed, one threw on a bright wrap, and the other simply seemed not to care. Not that this is ever going to happen to me because I always wear vintage to any balls I attend at the Vanderbilt mansion.

That is a great cover indeed, and I buy your version of the scenario. I worked in the art department at Glamour for 24 years. Unfortunately one of them was not 1944. Putting together the cover was THE most intense job— such scrutinizing as to the possible results of this or that cover line, this or that model, etc. I would love to have overheard what went on in that meeting…
What a great cover! Those jackets are so stylish. Several years ago I walked in to a dressy event and the first person I saw had on the exact same (expensive) suit I did. It really ruined the evening for me. Now I don’t have that problem anymore – that’s one happenstance that personal dressmaking eliminates!
I love the colors of those coats!
I think it’s only okay to see someone else with the same accessories when it comes to showing up in the same outfit today – but it is still hugely embarrassing to have on the same oufit. There are constant “news” articles of celebrities wearing the same outfit (sometimes months apart) and people comparing and deciding who wore it better – so stupid.
This story reminds me of that I Love Lucy episode where Lucy and Ethel buy the same gown to wear during a duet at a show then end up tearing each others gown to bits while singing about friendship
Oh, that *was* funny!